Homeowners often consider their Zestimate to be the accurate market value of their home.
While Zestimates are a great place to start, they are just what they claim to be- estimates.
A Zestimate is one example of an Automated Valuation Model (AVM) – a computer-generated tool that uses public data and algorithms to estimate a home’s worth.
Today, we’re going to break down the difference between automated valuation tools and a professional home appraisal, including which one is more accurate and when each type of valuation model is most useful.
Let’s get into it.
Zestimate vs. Appraisal
A Zestimate is Zillow’s automated estimate of your home’s value, based on public data such as square footage, bedroom count, and recent neighborhood sales.
It’s a helpful starting point, but algorithms can’t account for conditions, upgrades, or unique features, and outdated records can often cause inaccuracies.
For example, if your finished basement isn’t in county records, your Zestimate could be off by tens of thousands of dollars.
An appraisal, on the other hand, is a professional, in-person valuation by a licensed appraiser.
While AVMs rely solely on public data, appraisals go further: combining that information with an on-site inspection and a review of verified local sales.
Appraisers consider details that algorithms may overlook, such as layout, materials, quality, and current market trends.
TAG’s COO, Nathan, explains:
“We measure and inspect the home. Zillow never does that. We use real comparable sales and current listings to support every value”.
TAG Tip: Even Zillow clarifies that “a Zestimate home valuation is Zillow’s estimated market value, not an appraisal”. It’s meant as a starting point, not an exact number.
Why the Two Valuations Don't Always Match
It’s common for appraisals and AVMs to reach different conclusions on market value.
That doesn’t mean either number is completely wrong. It simply means they’re built differently.
Here’s why those values vary.
Reason
What Happens
Real-World Examples
Outdated or Incomplete Data
Zillow pulls from public records that can be missing or inaccurate.
A finished basement in Statesville doesn’t appear in county records, so Zillow undervalues the home.
Missed Upgrades and Additions
Algorithms can’t recognize remodels, additions, or improvements.
A Mooresville kitchen expansion adds livable space that Zillow doesn’t detect.
Quality and Detail Differences
Algorithms ignore craftsmanship and finishes that impact market appeal.
“Zillow never considers details like crown molding, trim, work, or higher-end finishes”– Nathan Jordan, TAG
Market Lags and Local Trends
Zillow’s data updates more slowly than real-time market shifts.
As Charlotte grows, nearby areas like Troutman become more desirable, but Zillow’s numbers lag.
Different Platforms, Different Formulas
Each site (Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com) uses a different algorithm, producing varied results.
One home in Clayton showed $144K on Zillow, $152K on Realtor.com, and $119K on Redfin- all with different square footage listed.
When to Rely on an Appraisal Over a Zestimate
Zestimates and other online estimates are helpful starting points for homeowners looking to buy, sell, or refinance.
But when it’s time to pull the trigger, accuracy matters. And nothing replaces a professional appraisal.
Here are the situations where you’ll want a verified valuation from a licensed appraiser:
- Buying or Refinancing a Home: Lenders require an appraisal to confirm a property’s market value.
- Pre-Listing Before Selling: Get an accurate price before listing your home.
- Property Tax Appeals: Support your appeal with a defensible, data-backed report.
- Estate Planning or Divorce: Date-of-death or retro appraisals provide official valuations for legal and tax purposes.
- Rural or Unique Properties: When there aren’t enough comparable sales, an appraiser’s expertise is essential.
TAG’s COO explains:
“It’s not that Zestimates are useless. They’re sometimes close to our appraisal values when the neighborhood data is strong. But for anything important, you need a real appraisal”.
The Bottom Line
Zestimates are great for curiosity; appraisals are for confidence.
Your home isn’t just a data point in an algorithm; it’s a reflection of real market value, local expertise, and human understanding.
At TAG, we combine on-the-ground insight, verified MLS data, and decades of real-world experience to deliver appraisals that withstand both financial decisions and legal review. TAG us in!
Connect with Rachel Mann on LinkedIn:
Thanks for reading! We love sharing insights from the TAG team, and we’re always looking to connect with others who are passionate about real estate, marketing, and community.
Have thoughts to share or want to collaborate on a future post? Let’s talk!